I have already ran through the portforwarding.com thing for my router and for WA. I also made sure that my firewall allows connections on all of the same ports that i am allowing to be forwarded. There-in lies my question. In WA itself what do I put in where it has "Player Information" and also "Firewall Support"? What should I have checked and what should I put in those fields in order to get hosting to work?

Nothing, that information is only for configuring proxy servers and doesn't really work anyway.